Tomatoes on Trial, Lindsay H. Metcalf
Tomatoes on Trial, Lindsay H. Metcalf
List: $7.99 | Sale: $5.60
Club: $3.99

Tomatoes on Trial
The Fruit v. Vegetable Showdown

Author: Lindsay H. Metcalf

Narrator: Johnny Heller

Unabridged: 14 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Publisher: Recorded Books

Published: 11/04/2025


Synopsis

Is a tomato a fruit or a vegetable? The US Supreme Court takes on the case in this juicy history book for kids ages 7 to 10. In the late 1800s, American produce king John Nix just wanted to sell tomatoes. But when import taxes on popular vegetables impacted his profits, he knew he had to remedy the situation. Nix set out to prove that tomatoes, which have seeds and grow on vines, were clearly fruits. That was the claim Nix argued all the way to the US Supreme Court. With Nix on Team Fruit, and the US government on Team Vegetable, both sides slung definition after definition in an epic, legal food fight. This little-known agriculturally based story from American history will fascinate young readers and encourage them to take a stand and defend their opinions. ★ "The Supreme Court battle over the definition of a tomato plays out in a humorous children's […] book which is most certainly guilty of being a remarkable read."—Shelf Awareness, starred review

Reviews

Goodreads review by Ember Air on August 08, 2025

Tomatoes on Trail is a true-crime adventure that takes the reader through the fascinating case of Tomato vs. Tomato. Fruit, Vegetable, something else entirely? What exactly is a tomato? How much do you think you know about how this classic food got its label? The readers follow along as John Nix (an......more

Goodreads review by Jan on February 24, 2025

Real history and a lesson in lawsuits, import taxing/tariffs, debating, and what does it mean to be a vegetable or fruit. Good classroom material with high learning potential. The illustrations by Edwin Fotheringham are imaginative, attention-getting, delightfully colorful, and FUN! Well suited for re......more

Goodreads review by Dorothea on November 16, 2025

Once in a while, a book comes into your life that surprises you. This is one of those books. I love picture books because of the simplicity of their stories and the beautiful and unique artwork that can accompany them. In this case, it was the surprising education that I received. This is not only a......more

Goodreads review by Melanie on October 22, 2025

Such a funny, punny look at how the tomato officially became a vegetable (spoiler!) following the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1893 decision. The language is wonderful, “After six years of stewing, the case boiled over into the US Supreme Court,” and the illustrations depicting the Team Fruit plaintiffs ver......more

Goodreads review by Alicia on November 18, 2025

The debate about whether a tomato is a fruit or a vegetable made it all the way to the Supreme Court and this picture book details that fight from the people who wanted to challenge the conventional thinking (it came down to imports/exports and money OBVIOUSLY). In addition to outlining what the arg......more