Earth to Earth, John Cornwell
Earth to Earth, John Cornwell
List: $31.99 | Sale: $22.40
Club: $15.99

Earth to Earth
Lives and Violent Deaths of a Devon Farming Family: A True Crime Classic Revisited

Author: John Cornwell

Narrator: Phillipe Bosher

Unabridged: 6 hr 42 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Publisher: riverrun

Published: 04/10/2025


Synopsis

On Tuesday morning, 23rd September 1975, the corpses of three unmarried siblings, last surviving members of the ancient Luxton clan of Winkleigh, North Devon, were found on their remote farm. All three had had their heads blown off. Robbie's cheeks and neck had been stabbed; Frances had a broken leg. Strangely, each of the four doors to the house had been locked from the inside.

The Luxtons' idyllic farm on a stretch of lush countryside between Exmoor and Dartmoor had been lovingly tended with outdated methods. There were rumours of a thwarted betrothal, wrangles over money and property, generational feuds in the extended family, bouts of insanity and extreme miserliness.

John Cornwell's classic investigation into the violent deaths of these unhappy siblings told a story of a farming family struggling under unbearable practical and emotional pressures, their violent deaths, the police investigation and the proceedings of the inquest. The official verdict was that there had been a suicide pact, but Cornwell decided to revisit the evidence forty years after Earth to Earth was first published, and he finds that there were anomalies in the evidence suggesting alternative, criminal scenarios, and the misery that preceded these savage deaths suggested even darker elements.

Were the Luxtons scapegoats of local malice, or victims of a murderous family conflict, stricken by a dire ancestral curse?

This new edition of a true crime classic includes a postscript in which the author describes the extraordinary lengths that the great poet Ted Hughes, a neighbour of the Luxtons, went to try and suppress publication of the book.

About John Cornwell

John Cornwell is the New York Times bestselling author of Hitler's Pope and many other books on Catholicism, a regular contributor to Vanity Fair and the Sunday Times (London), and a historian based in Cambridge, England. In 2019 he won the coveted Wilbur Award for best American magazine feature on religious affairs. He is widely known as a trusted expert on the Vatican and the modern papacy.


Reviews

Goodreads review by David on January 11, 2023

John Cornwell’s masterly,sympathetic and admirably thorough investigation of tragic Mid Devon farming siblings who, having no heirs, found they had nothing to live for and died at their own hands. This is 1975, secluded West Chappel farm near Winkleigh is where generations of the Luxtons have been wo......more

Goodreads review by Richard on January 05, 2018

Dug this out for a reread, after lapping it up on its publication in the 1980s. Acclaimed then as a real page turner, chronicling the history and tragic end of the Luxtons, an ancient mid-Devon farming family, now I'm afraid the sensationalism and disputed facts of the story (many locals were incens......more

Goodreads review by Colin on July 24, 2015

I came across this by accident while searching for another book altogether and I'd never heard of the tragic case of the multiple deaths of the Luxton siblings on their mid-Devon farm in 1975. John Cornwell's forensic analysis of a family's fall from wealth and influence to grinding hard work, self-......more

Goodreads review by Callum on October 21, 2024

found this incredibly fascinating as the case happened so close to my family's farm and was in fact the basis of one of my uncles plays! independently it is a thoughtful, gripping exploration of the fate of a family that is careful to avoid cliche trappings......more

Goodreads review by Peter on March 16, 2018

An easy to read,very interesting true story about a family tragedy.Well worth a read although ultimately very sad.......more


Quotes

Cornwell approaches it with the tenacity of an investigative journalist, the sympathy of a social worker drawing up case notes and the descriptive capacity of a novelist. What differentiates his book from the mass of true life crime stories is its insistence on making vivid for us not only the loud horror of the Luxtons' deaths, but the 40 years of claustrophobic rage, bred in silence, that preceded them New York Times

Exceptional true crime in the tradition of Truman Capote's In Cold Blood, a forensic examination of three mysterious killings but also an utterly absorbing portrait of a family, a region and a way of life. The new coda about Ted Hughes and the publication of the original book, fascinating in itself, adds a new, unsettling dimension to the whole story. A rich, compelling and powerful book.

John Cornwell marries the cool-headed forensic skills of the investigative journalist with the warmth and humanity of a true storyteller. The result is an utterly absorbing account of this great tragedy, revealing the many smaller, day-to-day tragedies which set a country family on the path to such a savage end.

On first reading, a gripping true crime unravels before the reader; at a deeper level, it is a profound meditation on truth, reality, and what can, ultimately, be known. An instant classic.

Earth to Earth is both chilling and thrilling, telling a mysterious story of the sequestered lives and tragic deaths of a Devon farming family. The account of the poet Ted Hughes's efforts to suppress the book will come as no surprise to anyone with reservations about this self-appointed shaman - a word only one syllable longer than 'sham'.

Earth to Earth is a family tragedy, a clinching argument for the importance of journalism and truth-seeking - and an irresistible storytelling treat from top to tail. The Times

It stands the test of time today. This is a dark, penetrating, compulsive book. The Spectator

Welcome back, Earth to Earth . . . Penetrating thickets of rural suspicion, a painstaking trawl through the family archives to understand why the family was so wedded to their horribly old-fashioned and penny-pinching agricultural method, and the curious busybody involvement of local celebrity weirdo, the poet Ted Hughes. Strong Words

Earth to Earth, by John Cornwell, is a fully updated and revised edition of a true crime classic . . . there is a fascinating coda involving future Poet Laureate Ted Hughes, which adds an extra level of weirdness to an already strange and beguiling story. Choice Magazine

In it's second incarnation, [Earth to Earth] becomes not only a meditation on change, but also a reflection on the notion of truth . . . It is the best kind of compassionate, open-minded journalism, revealing a human story in all its oddity and contrariness TLS