Comanche Heart

Okay, I seem to be one of the few that didnt like this book very much. Dont get me wrong, it was well written, but there were some major story points that bugged me to no end! For one if you read Comanche Moon and know the character of Amy at all you will see in this book that her character has COMPLETELY changed! Shes almost nothing like she was in the first book which really bothered me because I like a strong female lead in a story. At one point I literally yelled at the book ‘geez girl grow a spine!’. I realize Anderson wrote in reasons for Amys apparent regression into the lamb shes become in this book but I just had a really hard time buying it. I dont think Amy would have digressed to that level. Does that make me a book snob? Probably, but what can I say. Anderson had such a great character with Amy in the first book it was a shame to see her change it.

3 Stars Well, this was a major disappointment. The story follows two characters that were introduced in the previous book Comanche Moon. In that book they were only 12 and 15 years old but they left such a lasting impression on me because of how pure their relationship was. At the time, Amywent thro......more

First off, you really need to read Comanche Moon by Catherine Anderson before Comanche Heart because that is where Swift and Amy's story begins. They fall in love at a young age and get betrothed in the Comanche way. Swift Antelope stays with his Comanche tribe during their fight against the whites......more

3.5 STARS! "Keep your eyes always on the horizon, golden one. What lies behind you is for yesterday." Though what worked so well for Hunter and Loretta in book 1 didn't quite translate for Amy and Swift, I still adore this family and this author. I can't wait to start Indigo'......more