The Certainty Trap, Ilana Redstone
The Certainty Trap, Ilana Redstone
List: $34.99 | Sale: $24.50
Club: $17.49

The Certainty Trap
Why We Need to Question Ourselves More—and How We Can Judge Others Less

Author: Ilana Redstone, Joe Walsh

Narrator: Lisa Larsen, Qarie Marshall

Unabridged: 10 hr 13 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Published: 11/26/2024


Synopsis

When we’re in the Certainty Trap, we tend to view people who disagree with us as hateful, ignorant, or just plain stupid. When it comes to heated social and political issues in particular, many of us know this feeling well—a consuming state of righteous indignation and moral outrage. And this response makes sense because our very certainty tells us that there are simple and obvious causes and solutions to the hot-button issues we care about most. But the things we care about the most are—far more often than not—morally and ethically complex. If the problems that divide us are inherently complicated, then a sense that the answers are obvious—and that anyone who disagrees must be deficient in some way—is misplaced. It's an oversimplification that both leads to and reflects faulty thinking. When we’re certain, we not only fail to recognize the possibility that we’re wrong but also fail to be clear about the principles and values that drive our disagreement in the first place. By committing to challenging and clarifying our thinking—by avoiding the trap certainty sets for us—we can increase social trust, reduce political polarization, and better address the world’s pressing challenges.

About Ilana Redstone

Ilana Redstone is a professor of sociology at the University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign and co-directs the Mill Institute at the University of Austin. More about her work is available at ilanaredstone.com.

About Joe Walsh

Joe Walsh is a former U.S. congressman and presidential candidate. He is currently host of the White Flag podcast.

About Lisa Larsen

Lisa Larsen is an audiobook narrator and voice artist whose voice can be heard around the world in audiobooks, commercials, e-learning projects, and corporate narrations. When not narrating from her Los Angeles home studio, she can be found wrangling her two young daughters or working on a remodeling project with her husband.

About Qarie Marshall

Qarie Marshall has narrated over thirty series for the Discovery Channel and the BBC. He has also been a guest voice on Comedy Central's Drawn Together and has recorded BBC radio plays, the in-flight programming for Virgin Atlantic Airlines, over eighty video games for the PlayStation and Xbox, and numerous audiobooks. In 2007, he was made an Associate Artist of The Purple Rose Theatre.


Reviews

Goodreads review by Jillian on December 19, 2024

This book points to the ways that too much certainty in one’s own beliefs can foster polarization—and what readers can do about it. As a journalist by profession, I loved this book’s central message to think more critically about facts that get taken for granted. The author’s arguments were largely s......more

Goodreads review by Mikhael on October 29, 2024

Read this on recommendation from a friend who knows the author. The friend got a lot of insight from it, but he felt like I might not learn many new lessons. He was right. Most of the deconstruction of certainty and the reinforcement of humility in this book can be cultivated in a high school litera......more

Goodreads review by Richard on April 28, 2025

Lots of verbiage but basically the key messages are "question your assumptions" and "keep an open mind."......more

Goodreads review by Sekar on January 20, 2025

Full review and summary. The main points of The Certainty Trap are: 1. The Dangers of Certainty: Our need to always be right has divided us, increasing political polarization, distrust, and moral outrage. Redstone argues that blind certainty traps us in narrow thinking and self-righteousness. This min......more

Goodreads review by Susan on February 27, 2025

Redstone makes the case for re-evaluating our positions, in politics, in business and our relationships. Many of our opinions are held without thought or examination, welded to our belief that we are "right". The current polarization of our American political realm is the evidence of the dilemma. Re......more