Love and Other Poisons, Lesley McDowell
Love and Other Poisons, Lesley McDowell
List: $31.99 | Sale: $22.40
Club: $15.99

Love and Other Poisons
a gripping historical tale of scandal and murder, based on a true story

Author: Lesley McDowell

Narrator: Helen McAlpine

Unabridged: 12 hr 40 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Publisher: Wildfire

Published: 07/17/2025


Synopsis

'A fascinating, forensic deep-dive' DENISE MINA

'Beautifully written, richly evoked and utterly gripping' EVA DOLAN

'A seductive tale of sex and death' SARA SHERIDAN

***

1857, Glasgow.

A young socialite named Madeleine Smith stands accused of murdering her lover. Thousands wait outside the court to hear the result. The scandalous nature of the affair, detailed explicitly in letters published in newspapers across the world, has made her case a worldwide sensation. But when the jury find themselves unable to decide whether she is guilty, they render a verdict of 'Not Proven' - and Madeleine is freed.

1927, New York.

Harry Townsend, a handsome Hollywood film scout believes he has found the woman once known as Madeleine Smith. He wants to tell her story on film for the new 'talkie' generation. Since her trial she has lived under many names, as a glamourous society hostess in bohemian Bloomsbury to the likes of Dante Gabriel Rossetti, George Bernard Shaw and William Morris. Until suddenly, in 1890, when she disappeared off the face of the earth.

Could this quiet, secretive widow of an Irish labourer be the same Madeleine Smith who once stood trial for murder and escaped?

She has one last secret to reveal. Will Harry persuade her to tell it?

***

More praise for Lesley McDowell:
'Riveting - a clever portrait of a fascinating, flawed heroine.' THE TIMES
'An intimate and enlightening tale of one of Romanticism's forsaken muses.' SUSAN STOKES-CHAPMAN
'An absorbing, intoxicating page-turner about a woman who deserves to be remembered.' JENNIFER SAINT
'A must-read. McDowell brings to vivid, embodied life; a flirtatious, flawed woman fighting for her place in a man's world.' THE HERALD

About Lesley McDowell

Lesley McDowell's debut novel The Picnic came out in 2007. In 2010 she published Between the Sheets: The Literary Liaisons of Nine 20th-Century Women Writers, which was shortlisted for the non-fiction prize at the 2011 Scottish Book Awards. Her second novel Unfashioned Creatures, about Mary Shelley's Scottish childhood friend, was published in 2013. Lesley was a literary critic for the Herald, Scotsman, Independent, TLS and others. She has a PhD on the work of James Joyce and has won three Creative Scotland writers' bursaries. Her third novel, Clairmont, is a historical retelling of the story of Lord Byron and the Shelleys from the perspective of his secret muse, Claire Clairmont. Love and Other Poisons is her fourth novel.


Reviews

Goodreads review by Helen on July 08, 2025

I wasn’t sure whether to read this new novel by Lesley McDowell as I didn’t get on very well with her last one, Clairmont. Although I liked her writing, I struggled with the structure, the way it would jump from one timeline to another and the lack of context to explain characters’ backgrounds and r......more

Goodreads review by Monika on July 22, 2025

New York, 1927. Ninety-two-year-old Mrs Lena Sheehy is approached by a young filmmaker from Hollywood, Harry Townsend. He believes her to be Madeleine Smith, who in 1857 was tried for the murder of her lover, Emile L’Angelier. Mrs Sheehy vehemently denies these accusations, but the young man is adam......more

Goodreads review by Amy on January 09, 2025

What to expect: - Dual timelines - Historical fiction novel (1857 Glasgow/1927 New York) - Mystery/Thriller - Murder trial - Based on a true story - Socialites/ privileged social class - Informative and interesting Author’s notes A story about a former socialite in 1857 Glasgow, who was accused of and g......more

Goodreads review by Margo on January 04, 2025

4.5⭐ for the story and 6 ⭐for the historical research/author's note I really enjoyed this - a beautifully written historical fiction novel which has a dual-timeline between the real-life Madeleine Smith murder case in 1850s Scotland, and 1920s New York (where a film company lackey is trying to track......more

Goodreads review by Jini Sam on July 04, 2025

Overall: 3 stars. Premise: A young socialite from Glasgow is accused of murdering her lover in a sensational trial that sweeps across the nation in the 19th century. 70 years later, a young g filmmaker hopes to unravel this mystery by bringing the now elderly woman out of her recluse. Based on a true......more


Quotes

A fascinating, forensic deep-dive into the true crime case of Madeleine Smith. Mesmerising.

A feverish period thriller about the seduction of a young Scottish heiress. Beautifully written, richly evoked and utterly gripping. Based on a true story this one deserves to be huge!

A gorgeously written, seductive tale of sex and death, that delves into the darkness of Victorian women's hidden lives.

It's an enthralling novel, a beautifully organised tale in which McDowell shifts the perspective with great skill . . . thoroughly enjoyable - a remarkably intelligent and at times very moving fictionalisation of an extraordinary life. The Scotsman

Meticulously researched . . . gripping throughout The Herald