I Am Agatha, Nancy Foley
I Am Agatha, Nancy Foley
List: $19.99 | Sale: $13.99
Club: $9.99

I Am Agatha

Author: Nancy Foley

Narrator: Jennifer Pickens

Unabridged: 6 hr 37 min

Format: Digital Audiobook Download

Published: 03/17/2026


Synopsis

“Surprising and spellbinding, I Am Agatha is a beautiful love story and meditation on grief, memory, art, and the deepest secrets we hold to keep living....And that extraordinary ending! Once I finished, I had to turn back to the beginning to reread and rethink through the whole story again.” —Angie Kim, author of Happiness Falls

For readers of Elizabeth Strout and Sigrid Nunez, a darkly funny and moving debut novel about the unforgettable Agatha, whose devotion to a widow with dementia (and an inconvenient attachment to her daughter’s grave) sparks a radical reckoning with life, loss, and love’s aftermath.

Agatha, a bristly painter fleeing her own darkness, decamps to rural New Mexico to live the reclusive life of a small-town curmudgeon. It is there she meets Alice, a mild widow with a deepening case of dementia who keeps steady vigil at her daughter’s backyard grave. Despite Agatha’s rough edges and fierce aversion to sentimentality, she surprises herself by falling in love, and her well-worn convictions begin to upend.

As Alice’s condition worsens, Agatha hatches a plan for them to live together at her remote residence at Mesa Portales. But when Alice’s wayward son comes along with different ideas—and Alice suddenly goes missing—Agatha takes matters into her own hands with the help of a faithful thirteen-year-old-neighbor, a pair of shovels, and her trusty pickup, embarking on an unusual mission that calls into question whether some secrets are better kept buried.

Sharp, watchful, at once thrillingly perceptive and hidden from herself, Agatha is as imposing as the vast landscape her rustic adobe home overlooks. Loosely inspired by the life of Agnes Martin, I Am Agatha introduces us to this irascible, indelible character who learns—over a stretch of strange, singular days—new ways to fathom life, death, and her own heart.

About Nancy Foley

Nancy Foley grew up in New Mexico. She has been a writer in residence at Hedgebrook, and divides her time between New Mexico and Oregon. I Am Agatha is her first novel.


Reviews

Goodreads review by Kate on February 26, 2026

3.5 I Am Agatha is a historical fiction based on the life of reclusive painter, Agnes Martin (who left New York in 1967 and turned up in New Mexico 18 months later). Agatha lives almost a hermit's life on Mesa Portales, which is land belonging to Alice Roberts, with whom Agatha is in love. However, Al......more

Goodreads review by James on October 05, 2025

Thanks to Netgalley and Avid Reader Press for the ebook. Agatha is an accomplished artist who likes things her way on her schedule. Now in her golden years, she moves to a remote location to paint in peace, but falls for a widow named Alice. It’s always funny watching an exacting person who can’t co......more

Goodreads review by Sarah on March 08, 2026

If I had to pick one word to describe this book, it would be spare. There are few extraneous details, minimal background given on the main character, and not much in the way of plot. That is not to said, however, that these are drawbacks. Rather, they are fitting for a main character inspired by an......more

Goodreads review by Lucy on March 17, 2026

Loosely based on a short period in the life of painter Agnes Martin, Nancy Foley’s debut novel I Am Agatha is a lesson on writing companionship, grief and memory. Agatha loves Alice. She desperately wants Alice to move into her isolated hut, and to shut the two of them off from the world. But Alice’s......more

Goodreads review by Emily on February 22, 2026

Honestly, I was a little surprised by how much I enjoyed this book! It's a bit outside my usual genre preferences, but I decided to give it a try anyway based on the sapphic and somewhat mysterious angle, and I'm very pleased I did. I Am Agatha is the story of eccentric and somewhat misanthropic art......more